Žrtve drugog svetskog rata u Jugoslaviji

18

Žrtve drugog svetskog rata u Jugoslaviji

offline
  • Pridružio: 21 Maj 2008
  • Poruke: 14799

Napisano: 23 Jul 2011 19:30

Kibo ::Nego meni bi bio interesantan podatak koliko je stradalo nemackih i italijanskih vojnika za vreme WWII na teritoriji Jugoslavije.
Кибо, ево ти доста тога на енглеском...

Citat:German Casualties in the Balkans
The personnel records for German forces in the Balkans in World War II are fairly complete. (See above for the casualties reported in the initial invasion.) The reports include personnel casualties for the occupation forces for every ten-day period from 22 June to 20 December 1941. Irregular periodic casualty reports of the German occupation forces in the Balkans and Greece from 15 January to 21 October 1942 and 20 January to 28 February 1943 are also extant. Finally, ten-day reports for the Second Panzer Army from September 1943 when it began anti-Partisan operation in the Balkans under command of AG F, to December 1944 when it was reassigned to the direct control of OKH are available. From these reports it is possible to recreate the greater part of the German loss experience in anti-partisan operations in the Balkans.
The initial German casualties, incurred in the invasion of Yugoslavia and Greece between 6 and 27 April 1941 were 932 KIA, 3,773 WIA, and 257 MIA. Then from 28 April to 22 June the occupation forces recorded no casualties. However, severe losses were incurred in the airborne assault on the island of Crete (20 – 31 May 1941). German losses were: Luftwaffe 1,032 KIA, 1,632 WIA, 2,097 MIA; Army (5. Gebirgs-Division) 321 KIA, 488 WIA, 324 MIA. The 5,894 lost in the battle for Crete accounted for 54.29 percent of the Germans total loss in the campaign.
From 22 June to 31 August 1941 German casualties were 67 KIA and 112 WIA, and average of just over 2.6 casualties per day. During this period popular uprisings erupted sporadically in areas occupied by the Axis forces – 7 July in Serbia, 13 July in Montenegro, 22 July in Slovenia, and 27 July in Croatia, Bosnia, and Herzegovina. All of these uprisings were suppressed with savage force. However, by early September 1941 the Partisan movement had taken strong hold in western Serbia and established its headquarters in Uzice (thus it was known as the ‘Uzice Republic’). The first major German anti-Partisan offensive, spearheaded by the 342. Infanterie-Division drawn from France, was directed against the Uzice Republic and lasted from about 1 September 1941 to 20 December 1941. On 29 November the Germans captured Uzice, and the Partisans withdrew to northeastern Montenegro and then to eastern Bosnia. German casualties totaled 149 KIA, 325 WIA, and 194 MIA, an increase to an average of nearly six casualties per day.
After a short lull the German offensive resumed. From 15 to 29 January 1942 the 342. and 718. Divisions, reinforced by Croatian troops, attacked Partisan positions in Bosnia. They lost 25 KIA, 131 WIA and 1 MIA (about 10.5 casualties per day), but again forced the Partisans to retreat, this time further south to Foca. Secondary operations in Bosnia continued from 16 February to 20 March, resulting in another 37 KIA, 67 WIA, and 45 MIA (about 4.5 casualties per day).
Then, from 21 March to 21 October 1942, the Germans and their Allies continued to harry the Partisans, driving them from one enclave to another. Although the Partisans had some successes, usually against the German Croatian, Bulgarian, or Italian Allies, they continued to suffer heavy casualties. Partisan losses for 1942 have been estimated as 24,700 KIA, 31,200 MIA (including 4,194 DOW), and 6,300 MIA. The Germans also reported counting 45,692 Partisans or suspected Partisans killed (including executed prisoners) from 22 June 1941 to 23 July 1942. German losses to the end of the year were 295 KIA, 596 WIA, and 45 MIA, for a total of 320 KIA, 727 WIA, and 46 MIA for the year. German casualties in anti-Partisan operations through the end of 1942 were 573 KIA, 1,231 WIA, and 291 MIA, a pinprick compared to the losses on the Eastern Front (according to different sources, the Wehrmacht KIA on the Eastern Front, through the end of summer 1942, were between 376,290 and 501,884).
Another short lull occurred as both the Partisans and the Axis forces paused to recover and consolidate. Then, from 20 January to 28 February 1943, the Germans began an all-out effort to eliminate the Partisan forces in Fall Weiss I. Four German and Allied divisions (SS-Prinz Eugen, 369. Croat, 717., and 718.), with the support of the two available armored battalions in the Balkans, seized Partisan positions in western Bosnia and Croatia, and forced the partisans to withdraw south again to Montenegro. German losses were 385 KIA, 1,001 WIA, and 102 MIA, a major increase (an average of 39.7 casualties per day) over similar periods in 1942.
Casualties for the period from 1 March to 1 September 1943 have not been discovered. However, it is possible to derive a reasonable estimate of what those casualties must have been by subtracting the total known losses suffered by OB-Southeast (AG E) in the Balkans as of 28 February 1943 (2,211 KIA, 6,493 WIA, 974 MIA) from the losses of AG E as given up to 31 October 1943 (2,775 KIA, 7,067 WIA, and 1,938 MIA and another 15 KIA and 74 WIA in the recapture of Cos and Samos in October). The result – 549 KIA, 500 WIA, and 964 MIA for an aggregate total of 2,013 – is probably close to the actual losses incurred. Given that Fall Weiss 1 was immediately followed by Weiss 2 and Schwartz (Black), which lasted until the end of June, an additional 2,000 or more casualties could easily have been incurred at only one-half of the daily average rate found in Weiss 1 (39.7 casualties per day over 122 days would have been over 4,800 casualties). However, the distribution of the KIA, WIA, and MIA is more difficult to explain, but is likely a result of various casualty recalculations and redistributions that were a normal part of the statistical compilations of the Wehrmacht, as well as the brutal nature of the anti-Partisan war itself.
In any case, it appears that the first eight months of 1943 represented a major increase in the German casualties in the Balkans. After losing fewer than 3,700 men in the 16 months of anti-Partisan operations from the end of June 1941 to the end of October 1942, the Germans lost nearly the same number of casualties (3,590) in the first eight months of 1943. However, the intensity of the Partisan War in the Balkans had only begun to increase.
In September 1943 the Second Panzer Army took over command of anti-Partisan operations in the Balkans. Intense fighting occurred during September and October, especially after the capitulation of Italian forces to the Allies on 8 September 1943. German, Bulgarian and Croatian forces took over the former Italian territories in the Balkans. Some of the Italian forces went over to the Partisans and some went over to the Axis, but the majority was disarmed and interned by the Germans, most of those who resisted disarmament were executed. By the end of the year the German Second Panzer Army had incurred a further 1,622 KIA, 4,807 WIA, and 928 MIA, doubling the losses of the first eight months of 1943 in just four months at the end of the year. Units under the direct command of AG F lost an additional 6 KIA, 20 WIA, and 8 MIA. Partisan losses for 1943 were 48,378 KIA, 61,730 WIA (including 7,923 DOW) and 5,423 MIA.
The intensity of operations remained high in the early part of 1944. From 1 January to 20 May the losses of the Second Panzer Army were 1,899 KIA, 5,218 WIA, and 3,985 MIA. Units under AG F lost 145 KIA, 276 WIA, and 43 MIA in the same period. Then, the last major German attempt to crush the Partisans occurred on 25-27 May 1944 when a combined airborne and armored assault, code-named Fall Rösselsprung (Operation Knight’s Move) was directed on the village of Drvar. The Germans were attempting to decapitate the Partisan command by capturing or killing Tito (Josip Broz) the commander of the General Staff of the National Liberation Partisan Detachments of Yugoslavia. The total of the Second Panzer Army losses in the operation, its preliminaries and aftermath (the period from 21 May to 10 June) were 620 KIA, 1,869 WIA, and 285 MIA. Partisan casualties are unknown, but were severe as well. However, Tito made good his escape and established a new headquarters on the island of Vis in the Adriatic Sea. Losses in AG F units were 30 KIA, 74 WIA, and 6 MIA.
From 11 June to 30 November 1944, when the German Second Panzer Army was transferred from the command of OB Southeast and AG F to OKH and AG XXXX, it lost an additional 2,384 KIA, 8,181 WIA, and 3,110 MIA in battles with the Partisans. AG F losses from 11 June to the end of 1944 were 377 KIA, 1,193 WIA, and 554 MIA. Losses suffered by AG E in the withdrawal from Greece, 1 October to 31 December 1944 were 2,876 KIA, 9,637 WIA, and 3,823 MIA. Overall, it appears that the German losses in the anti-Partisan War in the Balkans in 1944 were 8,331 KIA, 26,448 WIA, and 11,806 MIA. Partisan losses for the year were 80,650 KIA, 147,650 WIA (including 8,066 DOW), and 5,600 MIA.
German losses in OB Southeast from 1 January to 20 April 1945 were 5,678 KIA, 20,110 WIA, and 8,638 MIA. Partisan losses in 1945 were 72,925 KIA, 130,000 WIA (including 7,800 DOW), and 7,800 MIA. However, it may be correct to say that the Partisan War in the Balkans ceased to be an insurgency sometime in September and October of 1944. From that time it assumed more and more of the attributes of a conventional conflict – indeed, in November 1944 the Partisans fielded the first of two armored brigades against the Germans (see above).
Consolidated reports on German losses in the Balkans from April 1941 to May 1945 may also be found. One states that casualties in the Balkans from the invasion of Yugoslavia to the end of the war included 24,267 KIA, and 12,050 MIA. Another (found in the same document) states that casualties in OB Southeast (i.e., the Balkans including Greece) were 19,235 KIA, 55,069 WIA, and 14,805 MIA for a total of 89,109. No reason was given for the discrepancy between these two figures. However, the Heeresartz made a more precise count, reporting that as of 20 April 1945, a total of 22,370 KIA, 70,064 WIA, and 24,620 MIA (a total of 117,054) had been lost in OB Southeast. That would mean that the 43,422 casualties incurred by the Second Panzer Army from 1 September 1943 to 30 November 1944 accounted for 34 percent of all of the casualties incurred by OB Southeast for the entire war.

Notes: (sorry they get lost cuting and pasting, I hope it remains obvious what they apply to.

The casualty reports for 22 June to 20 December 1941 and 15 January to 21 October 1942 may be found in the records of the Twelfth Army, Tätigkeitsberichte (Activity reports) in NARA RG242, T312, R462, F0379-0402 and R465, F3239~, R466, and R467, ~F3707. Second Panzer Army losses may be found in T313, R196, F2602~. Losses by theater and army from 10 July 1943 to the end of the war may also be found in NARA RG 242, T78, R414, Der Heeresartz im Oberkommando des Heeres (Surgeon General of the High Command of the Army).
This total includes the reported losses of the Second and Twelfth Army. A later report of the Twelfth Army appears to contradict its earlier figures, however the increase was apparently caused by adding the losses of the 5. Gebirgs-Division on Crete.
Many different counts of German losses exist and there is some dispute as to exactly how many were suffered in the assault on Crete. The figures given here are from an analysis of the operations of the Twelfth Army prepared for the German Army General Staff and may be found in NARA RG242, T312, R469, F8671 and F8681. It appears that the Luftwaffe losses on Crete include flying personnel as well as the parachute infantry (who were part of the Luftwaffe rather than the Heer). Christopher Shores, et al, Air War for Yugoslavia, Greece and Crete 1940-41 (Grub Street: London, 1987) state that Luftwaffe aircrew losses were 75 KIA, 127 WIA, and 236 MIA.
NARA RG242, T312, R465, F3379.
See NARA RG242, T77, R826, F2114~, Zentralststistik der Menschenverluste im Kriege, 30 August 1944, which compares the KIA figures accumulated by the Heeresartz versus those of the Wehrersatzdienststellen (Military Replacement Office).
Overall losses of AG E in the occupation of Greece, Crete, and the Aegean Islands are difficult to assess since they overlap in part with the losses incurred in the Balkans prior to 31 October 1943. However, from 31 October 1943 to 30 September 1944 they were 1,932 KIA, 4,414 WIA, and 1,671 MIA. It appears likely that these include the losses incurred in retaking the island of Leros from the British and Italians in November 1943 – 242 KIA, 660 WIA, and 155 MIA.
Major Percy Schramm, Foreign Military Studies, MS# P-011, German Statistical Systems, (Historical Division: HQ US Army, Europe, ND). p.118
Ibid., p. 131.

http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?f=50&t=126080

За италијанске губитке има занимљива дискусија:
http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?f=75&t=68709
Има различитих процена-података, говори се о 10-ак хиљада погинулих.

Dopuna: 23 Jul 2011 19:46

sasans23 ::На жалост, то се не би могло рећи за осталих 17 конц-логора у НДХ, који су готово пали у заборав иако је у сваком од њих убијено на десетине хиљада лица. (Подсећамо на неке логоре и, својевремено, јавно саопштене податке о броју жртава: Паг – 12.550 убијених, Госпић – 10.000, Сремска Митровица – 10.000, Јадовно – 72.000...)

http://www.dverisrpske.com/sr-CS/o-nama/magazin/jasenovac-kriz-i-noz.php[/quote]
Аутор текта је наводио различите податке за број настрадалих, али вечина њих су ратне проене броја настрадалих, које су претеране. За новија истраживања погледати почетак теме.

Овде се наводи број од скоро 100 хиљада убијених у комплексу Јадовно - Госпић - Паг.
Не знам како су дошли до тог броја. Људски остаци су делом уништени, или никад нису ни ексхумирани.

Проф. Ђуро Затезало је на основу података о превозу људи железницом дошао до броја од 40.000 хиљада људи који је пребачен у тај комплекс, и већином побијен.
http://www.jadovno.com/djuro-zatezalo-jadovno-komp.....-1941.html
Оно што је врло битно у овом случају је што се види велик интензитет - у просеку преко 300 људи дневно током 4 и по месеца, почев од оснивања НДХ до уласка Италијана. При томе је практично покренут цео државни апарат на прикупљању и егзекуцији невиних људи. Из овога се јасно види да је политика НДХ од почетка била геноцидна.

Registruj se da bi učestvovao u diskusiji. Registrovanim korisnicima se NE prikazuju reklame unutar poruka.
offline
  • Kibo  Male
  • Legendarni građanin
  • Pridružio: 03 Okt 2007
  • Poruke: 7498
  • Gde živiš: gde i mnogi Srbi pre mene

Koliko sam mogao da procitam za Nemce, oni su imali oko 120.000 gubitaka. Mada, moram da priznam da nisam najbolje razumeo tekst. Jer se u tekstu navodi podrucje Jugoslavije i Grcke.

Italijani su tu prosli dosta "jeftinije".

Da se vratim kratko na Nemce. Ako se pogleda da su Nemci u Staljingradu imali gubitak od preko 200.000 vojnika, onda im i nismo naneli bas neke velike gubitke u roku od cetiri godine rata.

offline
  • Pridružio: 21 Maj 2008
  • Poruke: 14799

Kibo ::Da se vratim kratko na Nemce. Ako se pogleda da su Nemci u Staljingradu imali gubitak od preko 200.000 vojnika, onda im i nismo naneli bas neke velike gubitke u roku od cetiri godine rata.
...а ако упоредиш немачке и италијанске губитке у Бици за Француску, видећеш да су изгубили мање против њих, него у Југославији. А ту су се борили са две првокласне армије, не са кеим герилцима.

Али у оба случаја поредимо бабе и жабе.

offline
  • Nebojša Đokić
  • vojni istoričar
  • Pridružio: 03 Jun 2010
  • Poruke: 4066
  • Gde živiš: Novi Beograd

Sve cifre koje se iznose su prilično proizvoljne. Ali da krenemo redom.
Za nemačke gubitke u Aprilskom ratu se uporno iznosi podatak koji je Hitler izneo u Rajhstagu. Po podacima nemačkog oficira za vojnička groblja na prostoru Nedićeve Srbije iz maja 1944. godine u kampanji u aprilu 1941. godine Nemci su u operacijama protiv Jugoslavije imali oko 500 poginulih. Naročito je nepovoljna struktura gubitaka oko 180 su tenkisti. Ako pođemo od toga da na svakog poginulog tenkistu mora da bude 3 do 4 ranjena (od kojih je bar jedan trajni invalid - u oklopnim jedinicama preovlađuju opekotine) Nemci su imali trajno izbačenih oko 400 tenkista i oko 800 najmanje mesec dana proizilazi da je 5 stvarno angažovanih imalo oko 30% ljudstva izbačeno istroja najmanje na mesec dana (oko 10% trajno). Dalje Nemci tvrde da su izgubili 40 tenkova u napadu na Jugoslaviju ali oni u izgubljene tj uništene tenkove računaju samo one koji su više od 97% stradali sve ostalo su oštećeni samo sa različitim nivoom oštećenja. Ako koristimo metodologiju drugih armija iz vremena II svetskog rata Nemci su imali verovatno oko 100 otpisanih tenkova i najmanje još toliko na remontu dužem od mesec dana.
Da sve ovo nije preterivanje dovoljno govori podatak da ni jedna od 5 stvarno angažovanih pancer divizija nije bila operativno sposobna 22. juna 1941. godine.

offline
  • Kibo  Male
  • Legendarni građanin
  • Pridružio: 03 Okt 2007
  • Poruke: 7498
  • Gde živiš: gde i mnogi Srbi pre mene

vathra ::Kibo ::Da se vratim kratko na Nemce. Ako se pogleda da su Nemci u Staljingradu imali gubitak od preko 200.000 vojnika, onda im i nismo naneli bas neke velike gubitke u roku od cetiri godine rata.
...а ако упоредиш немачке и италијанске губитке у Бици за Француску, видећеш да су изгубили мање против њих, него у Југославији. А ту су се борили са две првокласне армије, не са кеим герилцима.

Али у оба случаја поредимо бабе и жабе.


Vathra u pravu si. Podatak bi bio jasniji kada bi znali koliko je tacno nemackih vojnika ucestvovalo u okupaciji Jugoslavije ali tokom celog WWII. Tu bi mozda bolje mogli videti neke stvari.

Za Francuze si sto posto u pravu, razbezali se ko babe. Englezi ih i dan danas zezaju zbog toga. Ako se pogleda da je u Jugoslaviji ipak postojala samo gerila, onda to izgleda vec sasvim drugacije. Ali da ne idemo sad vise u off-topic.

Meni je u svakom slucaju podatak bio jako interesantan.

Sada se setih jos necega. Podatak bi bio jos interesantniji kada bi znali za nemacke gubitke iz perioda kada Crvena Armija ulazi u Jugoslaviju.

Jeste, u pravu ste, mnogo sam dosadan, ali mnogo me interesuje istorija. Pogotovo podaci do kojih nije bas lako doci.

offline
  • Pridružio: 21 Maj 2008
  • Poruke: 14799

ltcolonel ::Sve cifre koje se iznose su prilično proizvoljne. Ali da krenemo redom.
Za nemačke gubitke u Aprilskom ratu se uporno iznosi podatak koji je Hitler izneo u Rajhstagu. Po podacima nemačkog oficira za vojnička groblja na prostoru Nedićeve Srbije iz maja 1944. godine u kampanji u aprilu 1941. godine Nemci su u operacijama protiv Jugoslavije imali oko 500 poginulih. Naročito je nepovoljna struktura gubitaka oko 180 su tenkisti. Ako pođemo od toga da na svakog poginulog tenkistu mora da bude 3 do 4 ranjena (od kojih je bar jedan trajni invalid - u oklopnim jedinicama preovlađuju opekotine) Nemci su imali trajno izbačenih oko 400 tenkista i oko 800 najmanje mesec dana proizilazi da je 5 stvarno angažovanih imalo oko 30% ljudstva izbačeno istroja najmanje na mesec dana (oko 10% trajno). Dalje Nemci tvrde da su izgubili 40 tenkova u napadu na Jugoslaviju ali oni u izgubljene tj uništene tenkove računaju samo one koji su više od 97% stradali sve ostalo su oštećeni samo sa različitim nivoom oštećenja. Ako koristimo metodologiju drugih armija iz vremena II svetskog rata Nemci su imali verovatno oko 100 otpisanih tenkova i najmanje još toliko na remontu dužem od mesec dana.
Da sve ovo nije preterivanje dovoljno govori podatak da ni jedna od 5 stvarno angažovanih pancer divizija nije bila operativno sposobna 22. juna 1941. godine.

Ово би били прилично велики губици тенковских посада, чак и да су укупно отписали 100 тенкова + 100 на дужем ремонту.

Савезничке статистике са европског војишта у последњој години рата наводе да је у тенковима било у просеку 2,5 жртава (у средњим са 5 чланова, и у лаким са 4 члана). Од тога је био један погинули, а од укупно погинулих половина је страдала ван возила.

Број погинулих би био одговарајући за 100 уништених + 100 тешко оштећених, али мислим да је број рањених превелик (3-4 пута већи), те да је однос од 2-2,5 рањена по погинулом реалнији, поготово јер је доста кориштених тенкова имало мање посаде, а ПТ топови су били мање разорни.

offline
  • Nebojša Đokić
  • vojni istoričar
  • Pridružio: 03 Jun 2010
  • Poruke: 4066
  • Gde živiš: Novi Beograd

Najveći deo gubitaka nemačkih tenkova u Aprilu 1941. godine otpada ne na protiv oklopnu već na protiv avionsku artiljeriju jugoslovenske vojske. Protiv avionsi topovi su koristili tzv polu pancirnu municiju kako se tada zvala a to su ustvari APHE zrna po savremenoj NATO klasifikaciji koja imaju nešto manju probojnost ali veliko razorno dejstvo nakon probijanja oklopa. Dejstvo naših PA topova je imalo strahovit efekat po pogođenim tenkovima. Postoji fotografija 3 uništena Pz IV kod Markovca kod Velike Plane a ispred njih 15 krstova tj grobova poginulih tenkista. Dalje, daleko najveći broj nemačkih tenkova je strada u klasičnim zasedama a ne pri proboju fronta. Dosta komandira tenkova (i vozača) je ranjeno ili poginulo jer su u momentu upadanja u zasedu bili delimično izvan tenka (naročito to važi za komandire koji su po pravilu od grudi pa naviše virili iz tenkova). Dosta nemačkih tenkista je stradalo i van tenkova jer su iznenađeni napadima naše bombarderske avijacije (npr u Kačaniku, kod Ćuprije itd). Naročito mnogo ljudi je stradalo (tj bilo ranjeno) u aufklarung abtajlunzima panzer divizija koji su vrlo često upadali u zasede. Premda municija 7,9 mm nije mogla da probije oklop tenkova Pz II kojim su oni bili uglavnom opremljeni dešavalo se vrlo često da pri direktnom pogotku tog zrna u bočni oklop tenka Pz II na daljinama manjim od 100 metara da dođe do otkidanja parčeta oklopa sa unutrašnje strane i ranjavanja članova posade. Itd ...

offline
  • Pridružio: 17 Maj 2007
  • Poruke: 13939

offline
  • Pridružio: 05 Jan 2011
  • Poruke: 1037

Napisano: 19 Jan 2012 7:08

vathra ::Citat:German Casualties in the Balkans
...Then from 28 April to 22 June the occupation forces recorded no casualties.

From 22 June to 31 August 1941 German casualties were 67 KIA and 112 WIA, and average of just over 2.6 casualties per day. ...

However, by early September 1941 the Partisan movement had taken strong hold in western Serbia and established its headquarters in Uzice (thus it was known as the ‘Uzice Republic’). The first major German anti-Partisan offensive, spearheaded by the 342. Infanterie-Division drawn from France, was directed against the Uzice Republic and lasted from about 1 September 1941 to 20 December 1941. On 29 November the Germans captured Uzice, and the Partisans withdrew to northeastern Montenegro and then to eastern Bosnia. German casualties totaled 149 KIA, 325 WIA, and 194 MIA, an increase to an average of nearly six casualties per day.

Casualties for the period from 1 March to 1 September 1943 have not been discovered. However, it is possible to derive a reasonable estimate of what those casualties must have been by subtracting the total known losses suffered by OB-Southeast (AG E) in the Balkans as of 28 February 1943 (2,211 KIA, 6,493 WIA, 974 MIA) from the losses of AG E as given up to 31 October 1943 (2,775 KIA, 7,067 WIA, and 1,938 MIA and another 15 KIA and 74 WIA in the recapture of Cos and Samos in October). The result – 549 KIA, 500 WIA, and 964 MIA for an aggregate total of 2,013...
Major Percy Schramm, Foreign Military Studies, MS# P-011, German Statistical Systems, (Historical Division: HQ US Army, Europe, ND). p.118
Ibid., p. 131.

http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?f=50&t=126080

Ove računice više imaju značaj otvaranja problema i prikupljanja izvora, nego što imaju vrednost u smislu zaključka.
Nesaglasnosti između raznih izveštaja, koje nisu male, problem su koji nije ni obrađen, ni objašnjen.

Na primer, ovde se zaključuje o ukupno 847 Nemaca izbačenih iz stroja (KIA 216, WIA 437, MIA 194) za period 22. jun - 31. decembar 1941.
Međutim, izvor iz komande Jugoistoka daje za isti period cifru od (KIA 276 + WIA 520 + MIA 394 = 1190) samo za posadne divizije 704, 714, 717, 718 - dakle, nisu uračunate 342 div, 113 div, 125 p.puk, još neki armijski bataljoni i druge službe i formacije.

(BORBA PROTIV USTANIČKOG POKRETA NA PODRUČJU JUGOISTOKA OD JUNA 1941. DO AVGUSTA 1942. GODINE - Obrada kapetana Ernesta Vishaupta, nemačkog vojnog istoričara pri komandantu oružanih snaga na Jugoistoku, http://www.znaci.net/00001/4_12_2_11.pdf )

Drugi primer: Ovde se zaključuje o 549 KIA, 500 WIA, and 964 MIA (ukupno 2013) za ceo period od 1. marta do 1. septembra 1943.

Nasuprot tome, IZVEŠTAJ KOMANDANTA NEMAČKIH TRUPA U NDH ( http://www.znaci.net/00001/4_12_3_94.pdf ) daje znatno veći broj, KIA 583 + WIA 1760 + MIA 425 (beru cveće po Zelengori) = ukupno 2768 - samo za operaciju Schwartz, tj za period 15. maj-15. jun 1943.

Jasno je da nemačke izveštaje ne treba uzeti bezrezervno kao tačne. Njihovi izveštaji o sopstvenim gubicima su korisna osnova za istraživanje. S druge strane, izveštaji o neprijateljskim gubicima su notorno preuveličavani. U ovoj kategoriji sve vojske imaju tendenciju da neprijateljske gubitke "procene" kao višestruko veće od realnih.

Dopuna: 19 Jan 2012 7:28

Postoji još jedna stvar koju treba imati u vidu kod nemačkih gubitaka u Jugoslaviji.
Naime, sve cifre i računice koje se uzimaju u obzir, odnose se na armijske jedinice.

Međutim, na teritoriji Jugoslavije postojale su i razne teritorijalne jedinice i straže, na primer landesshützen bataljoni i lokalna rezervna policija. Ovakvi gubici:

Napad NOVJ na Podgorač juna 1944. http://bit.ly/lISDGo

gde je naveden broj od 361 KIA, nisu u tim zbirovima nigde uračunati. (Mesto je zauzeto, niko nije pobegao, gubici su prebrojani - u takvim situacijama ovakvi izveštaji manje preteruju.)

Pored toga, u svim garnizonima u NDH bili su prisutni predstavnici raznih nemačkih službi, obaveštajci, vezisti, pripadnici raznih organizacija i administracija, vojna i civilna policija, pripadnici SD. Ovi nemački delovi, čija je brojnost bila nekoliko desetina, često su predstavljali jezgro najupornijeg otpora tokom partizanskog napada na mesto (partizani ih sve zbirno nazivaju "gestapovcima", i u pravilu su, u slučaju da budu uhvaćeni, streljani). A takvih napada bilo je preko 300.

Otuda je za Jugoslaviju pogrešna metoda računati gubitke po ključu:

zbir gubitaka po divizijama = ukupni nemački borbeni gubitak.

Operativne divizije su većim delom korišćene za ofanzivne akcije, a manjim su držane kao posade. Stoga takva računica pokriva pretežno ofanzivne akcije, dok jedna vrlo brojna, vrlo zastupljena i značajna kategorija - napadi NOVJ na manje garnizone - ostaje nepokrivena.

Dopuna: 19 Jan 2012 7:52

vathra ::Consolidated reports on German losses in the Balkans from April 1941 to May 1945 may also be found. One states that casualties in the Balkans from the invasion of Yugoslavia to the end of the war included 24,267 KIA, and 12,050 MIA. Mislim da ovo nije tačno. Siguran sam da sam video izvore prema kojima se ove cifre odnose na period do 1. XII 1944 (što bi bilo i logično).
Ima li neko izvore pri ruci?

Dopuna: 19 Jan 2012 8:39

Evo ih na primer ovde:

German KIA, Balkans 1941 - 11.30.44: 24,267
http://www.feldgrau.com/stats.html

Ukratko, ovo gore je prilično površna analiza.

offline
  • Pridružio: 21 Maj 2008
  • Poruke: 14799

gorran :: Evo ih na primer ovde:

German KIA, Balkans 1941 - 11.30.44: 24,267
http://www.feldgrau.com/stats.html

Ukratko, ovo gore je prilično površna analiza.

Мислим да се горњи бројеви односе на цео Балкан (укљ. и Грчку), а бројеви из Андерсоновог рада само на Југославију.

Али и мени је чудно, мислим да су губици из десетодневних непотпуни.
http://www.vojska.net/eng/world-war-2/germany/casualties/1943/10/
Пример су 10-дневни губици за 369. пд - овде су наведени мањи губици него у извештају исте јединице од 10. октобра.

Такође, у овом извештају су наведени мањи губици за Априлски рат. Касније су објављени губици који су скоро 10 пута већа.

Иначе, Андерсонове бројке имамо лепо сложене овде:
http://www.vojska.net/eng/world-war-2/germany/casualties/pzaok2/

Иначе, погледајмо немачке губитке по овом извору од септембра 1943. до августа 1944. (једна година)
Убијени 5783
Рањени 17157
Нестали 4151
Ако претпоставимо да је 10% рањених касније умрло, као и да је 90% несталих мртво, долазимо до броја од око 11 хиљада убијених немаца, само за годину дана пре доласка совјета. А ови подаци највероватније нису комплетни.

Ko je trenutno na forumu
 

Ukupno su 765 korisnika na forumu :: 54 registrovanih, 10 sakrivenih i 701 gosta   ::   [ Administrator ] [ Supermoderator ] [ Moderator ] :: Detaljnije

Najviše korisnika na forumu ikad bilo je 3195 - dana 09 Nov 2023 14:47

Korisnici koji su trenutno na forumu:
Korisnici trenutno na forumu: A.R.Chafee.Jr., ajo baba, anbeast, Apok, Belac91, Ben Roj, bigfoot, bojcistv, BORUTUS, brundo65, bufanje, cifra, dankisha, darkojbn, djboj, djo97, DonRumataEstorski, dragoljub11987, flash12, Georgius, hatman, ILGromovnik, Istman, ivicasimo, Joja, kihot, Klecaviks, Kriglord, Kubovac, kunktator, kybonacci, loon123, Lord Nem, m0nstrum_, MB120mm, mgolub, mikrimaus, milenko crazy north, milos.cbr, Nemanja.M, nemkea71, nextyamb, NoOneEver Dreams, nuke92, opt1, pacika, panzerwaffe, Sićko, Srle993, Tvrtko I, vaso1, Vlajman1957, vrag81, zixmix